To initiate an exchange or return, click HERE


If for any reason you are not happy with your purchase, send it back within 30 days of the delivery date to receive a refund or to exchange for a different size or better fit. All products you wish to return or exchange must be in their original packaging. Please note that our exchange and return policy does not cover damage caused by improper use.

Once our team has received your returned order, we will credit your original form of payment. We process all returns manually and we ask that you please allow up to 2 weeks for your refund to be processed. Once processed, it can take up to 7 business days for a return credit to appear on your statement.

If you choose to purchase your own return label, please provide our team the with the tracking information so we can process it accordingly.

Please note that surplus and mystery products cannot be returned or exchanged.


We want you to get the right size and fit so exchanges are on us. Just send your shoes back within 30 days from when you received them and we’ll send you the shoe and style of your choice.

International Exchanges and Returns

At this time, we do not offer return shipping on orders placed outside of the United States. If you are an international customer and would like to exchange or return a pair of sneakers, please contact us at


We're dedicated to making quality products that stoke you out and we love talking to the people who support our brand. Hit us up with any questions you may have via email


Your Cart (0 item)

All Mystery Shoe purchases are final sale. Please double check that the size(s) you selected are correct before checkout.

Locker login

Don't have an account?

Create an account to access your York Locker, access special promotions and speed up future checkout experiences.

Create account

By creating an account, you agree to the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy of York Athletics.